| Programs
to Decrease Unprotected
Male to Male Sex |
| |
In
the U.S., the
largest proportion
of people with
HIV/AIDS is men
exposed to the
virus by having
sex with men.
This is true for
both rural and
urban areas.[1]
Consequently,
MSM are a primary
focus for HIV
prevention interventions.
Successfully implementing
programs to reduce
HIV and STD transmission
among MSM is a
particular challenge
in rural areas
in part due to
discrimination
and homophobia.
This seems to
apply regardless
of whether men
identify as gay
or bisexual, and
whether they are
open or secretive
about their behavior.
Although there
are few if any
venues for men
to socialize with
other men in rural
areas, social
networks may provide
a good way to
recruit men into
interventions.
Some MSM are fearful
of disclosing
their behavior
to avoid stigma,
discrimination,
and potential
violence so they
may be reluctant
to openly participate
in interventions.
The following
interventions
begin to address
some of these
challenges. However,
the first step
in any rural HIV/STD
behavioral intervention
is to assess the
community and
identify local
social networks.
This requires
gathering information
about the accessibility
of the target
audience, their
stage of readiness
to change, the
assets they bring,
the social or
sexual networks
in which risk
behaviors occur,
and cultural as
well as structural
influences that
might hinder or
support the implementation
of a program.
Rural adaptations
of MPowerment,
Community PROMISE,
and Many Men Many
Voices are described
along with two
locally developed
Tier 4 interventions,
one of which utilizes
the Internet.
It is clear that
more interventions
addressing rural
MSM and especially
rural MSM of color
are needed.
Adult
Men Who Have Sex
with Men
|
Target
Behaviors and Behavioral Determinants
Unprotected
male to
male sex;
lack of
venues
for safe
socialization;
perceived
lack of
power
and social
support.
Description
Adaptation
of MPowerment
(DEBI
from Original
Compendium)
www.mpowerment.org
This community-level
intervention
builds
positive
connections
among
men of
all ages
who identify
as gay,
bisexual,
or queer
and live
in rural
Colorado.
Regional
events
are hosted
in varying
locations.
Events
offer
a safe
space
for sharing
information,
socializing,
building
support,
and promoting
safer
sex. Modeling
healthy
behavior
and mentoring
are guiding
principals.
Statewide
gatherings
are held
each summer.
ManREACH
uses a
statewide
steering
committee
to plan
events.
Adaptation
Core elements
have
not
been
altered.
The
intervention
has
been
modified
to include
rural
MSM
of all
ages
and
takes
advantage
of rural
isolation
and
beauty
to provide
inviting
safe
venues
for
activities.
Evidence The
original
intervention
showed
a decrease
in unprotected
sex
and
a reduction
in new
HIV
infections
but
these
outcomes
have
not
been
measured
in the
adapted
program.
The
program
continues
to increase
its
reach
to rural
men
who
identify
as gay
or homosexual.
Recommendations
Holding
events
at multiple
sites
throughout
the
state
during
months
with
good
weather
increases
participation.
Developing
leadership
with
statewide
representation
of rural
MSM
is a
critical
component
for
success.
Where
Implemented
Rural
Colorado,
statewide
Contact
Information
www.manreach.org,
info@manreach.org
|
IMSexED
– Instant
Message
Sex
Education
|
Target
Behaviors and Behavioral Determinants Lack
of knowledge about HIV/STD risk
behaviors, disease symptoms, HIV
testing, clinic and testing locations,
local resources.
Target
Audience
Internet
users, especially
men who
have sex
with men
(MSM) who
use
online chatrooms
and sexual
hook-up
sites.
Description
IMsexED
builds on
the current
popularity
of the internet
to reach
rural MSM
and engage
them in
HIV-prevention
education
in a cost-effective
way. “Ed”
is personified
as a condom-like
caricature
and has
a profile
which informs
viewers
that his
function
is to provide
sexual health
related
information
and referrals.
The IMsexED
character
currently
makes itself
conspicuously
available
on gay.com,
adam4adam,
lifeout.com,
blackgaychat.com,
Yahoo Messenger,
Facebook,
Twitter
and can
be e-mailed
at IMsexED@arcw.org.
Depending
on the limitations
of each
particular
internet
site, IMsexED
will typically
and proactively
provide
information
(in the
form of
bullet points)
on common
sexual-health-related
topics such
as HIV/STD
risk factors,
disease
symptoms,
HIV testing,
clinic locations,
breaking
news/studies,
links to
helpful
sites, statistics,
etc. In
addition
to posting
important
information,
SexED invites
folks to
‘Instant
Message’
or ‘Private
Message’
for more
detailed
information
on sensitive
or personal
matters.
Evidence
There
is extensive
anecdotal
evidence
that “clients”
are
using
IMSexED
to get useful
information
and find
resources.
Recommendations
Nine
months
of planning
went into
the creation
of the
IMsexED
protocols,
which
include
specific
information
regarding;
ISP negotiations,
message
content,
resource/referral
lists,
internet
terminology,
internet
etiquette
and program
documentation/evaluation
techniques.
Where
Implemented
Wisconsin AIDS
Resource
Center
of Wisconsin
Contact
Information
Paul
Jacob,, HIV
Prevention
Specialist
AIDS
Resource
Center
of
Wisconsin
920-437-7400,
ext. 3110
paul.jacob@arcw.org |
|
Target
Behaviors
and
Behavioral
Determinants
Enhanced
self esteem
around
racial/ethnic
status
and sexual
behaviors,
unprotected
male to
male sex;
improved
partner
negotiation
and communication
skills.
Description
A 7-session group-level
DEBI
intervention
for
men
of color
who
have
sex with
men (MSM)
who
may
or may
not
identify
as gay.
3MV addresses
factors
that
influence
the
behavior
of men
of color
who
have sex
with
men:
cultural,
social,
and
religious
norms;
interactions
between
HIV
and
other
sexually
transmitted
diseases;
sexual
relationship
dynamics;
and
the
social
influences
that
racism
and
homophobiahave
on HIV
risk
behaviors.
Evidence
3MV participants
reported
significantly
greater
reductions
in
any
unprotected
anal
intercourse
with
casual
male
partners;
a
trend
for
consistent
condom
use
during
receptive
anal
intercourse
with
casual
male
partners;
and
significantly
greater
reductions
in
the
number
of
male
sex
partners
and
greater
increases
in
HIV
testing
Where
Implemented
Mississippi
State
Department
of Health
New
Mexico
AIDS
Services
Contact
Information
Mississippi
State
Department
of Health,
HIV Division
(601)
576-7723
New
Mexico
AIDS
Services
(505)
938-7100
or (888)
882-AIDS
|
Young
Men Who Have
Sex with Men
|
Target
Behaviors
and
Behavioral
Determinants
Unprotected
male to
male sex
among
young
MSM; lack
of adequate
knowledge
about
safer
sex behaviors;
lack of
venues
for safe
socialization;
perceived
lack of
power
and social
support.
Description
Adaptation
of MPowerment (DEBI)
Developed
by and for
young, rural
MSM ages
16-24, this
community-level
DEBI is
directed
by a small
core group
(8-10) of
gay and
bisexual
young men
with support
from AIDS
service
organization
staff. The
intervention
has four
integrated
activities.
Formal outreach
is conducted
by teams
that create
their own
social events
to attract
young rural
MSM and
promote
safer sex.
In contrast,
informal
outreach
involves
the core
group members
discussing
safer sex
with friends.
M-groups
are peer-led
2-3 hour
meetings
of 8-10
young rural
MSM to discuss
factors
contributing
to unsafe
sex. Through
skills-building
exercises,
the young
men practice
safer sex
negotiation
and correct
condom use
skills. Free
condoms
are provided
at all meetings.
*MpowerMT
also hosts
a yearly
Young Men’s
Health Retreat
in the spring
of every
year. All
MSM ages
16-24 are
invited
to spend
a weekend
at a secluded
lodge to
get to know
one another,
share information,
and learn
new things
regarding
sexual,
mental,
and physical
health.
These events
are facilitated
by the Montana
Gay Men’s
Task Force
and qualified
therapists.
These weekends
are free
to participants
and food
and lodging
are provided
for the
three day
event. An
ongoing
publicity
campaign
attracts
young men
throughout
the state
to the project
by word
of mouth,
the Internet,
and articles
or advertising
in gay newspapers.
The program
also identifies
and targets
locations
and events
where the
target audience
can be found
such as
PRIDE events,
GSA dances,
and drag
shows.
Adaptation
Core elements
remain
intact
and this
is the
age group
of the
original
DEBI.
*MpowerMT
has been
modified
to reflect
rural
culture
by discussing
issues
pertinent
to the
group
such as
discrimination
and social
isolation.
Evidence
The original
intervention
showed
a decrease
in unprotected
sex and
a reduction
in new
HIV infections
but these
outcomes
have not
been measured
in the
adapted
program.
Pre and
post-event
knowledge
assessments
consistently
show a
gain in
risk reduction
knowledge
of 80%
for those
completing
the assessment.
Recommendations
This intervention
is intended
to have
local
adaptations
and works
well in
rural
Montana
to reach
the entire
community
of young
gay and
bisexual
men and
support
safer
sex behaviors
through
community
empowerment.
Where
Implemented
Montana
Contact
Information
www.mtgayhealth.org
1-888-713-4683
|
VIBES (Very Informed
Brothers
Engaged
for Survival) |
Target
Behaviors
and Behavioral
Determinants
Unprotected
male to
male sex
among young
African
American
men; lack
of cultural
pride; perception
of lack
of power;
lack of
condom negotiation
and relationship
negotiation
skills;
lack of
personal
sense of
responsibility
for sexual
safety;
lack of
goal-setting
skills,
lack of
problem-solving
skills.
Description
VIBES
is a theory
guided,
research
based group-level
six-session
behavioral
HIV prevention
intervention
for young
rural African-American
MSM. The
intervention
develops
decision-making
and condom
negotiation
skills,
helps youth
create risk
reduction
strategies,
and advances
cultural
empowerment.
Evidence
Youth
who participated
in the VIBES
intervention
experienced
significant
gains in
condom use
and risk
reduction
skills as
compared
to a control
group of
youth receiving
basic HIV
education. Effectiveness
data
are
being
collected
currently.
Recommendations
Please
see the
VIBES curriculum
for lesson
plans, and
implementation
suggestions.
Illinois
Department
of Public
Health provides
training
on this
intervention.
Where
Implemented
Illinois,
Indiana
Contact
Information
VIBES
Jeffery
Erdman at
Champaign-Urbana
Public Health
District
(217)
239-7827
jerdman@c-uphd.org
|
|
Target
Behaviors
and
Behavioral
Determinants
Positive
identify
development;
positive
youth
development;
reduced
unprotected
male to
male sex;
increased
perception
of HIV
risk;
increased
risk reduction
skills;
increased
peer education
skills.
Description
Locally
developed
intervention
provides
8 hours
of training
to peer educators
to facilitate
HIV
risk
reduction
education
among
18-24
year
old
men
who
have
sex
with
men.
After
training,
peer
educators
are
supported
monthly
meetings
and
booster
sessions.
YEAH!
is based
on positive
youth
development
theory
and
incorporates
a popular
opinion
leader
approach
through
which
the
“coolest
guys
share
the
coolest
information
and
distribute
the
coolest
condoms.”
The
program
develops
protective
youth
assets
including
confidence,
competence,
character,
connections,
and
contributions
to their
community.
In addition,
YEAH!
places
socially
marketed
condom
dispensers
in
venues
where
young
MSM
congregate.
Focus
groups
with
members
of
the
target
population
determined
the
most
appropriate
educational
approaches
and
selected
the
branding
for
the
intervention.
Evidence
Pilot
evaluation
results
demonstrated
that
peer
educators
achieved
statistically
significant
gains
in knowledge
(p<.001,
n=23),
comfort
talking
about
HIV
risk
behaviors
(p=.005,
n=20),
confidence
talking
about
HIV
risk
behaviors
(p<.001,
n=21),
and
self-efficacy
for
HIV
prevention
and
peer
education
(p<.001,
n=21.
Qualitative
data
from
peer
educators
showed
that
many
participants
perceived
YEAH!
to have
contributed
to their
leadership
development
and
most
believed
they
had
an
impact
at the
community
level.
Between
June
2010
and
February
2011, YEAH!
distributed
approximately
11,000
condoms
through
peer
educators
and
condom
dispensers,
providing
opportunities
to open
discussions
about
reducing
HIV
risk
behaviors
with
clients.
Peer
educators
participated
in formal
community-based
peer
education
activities
at the
Bisexual,
Gay,
Lesbian,
and
Straight
Alliance
at the
University
of South
Carolina,
South
Carolina
Pride,
South
Carolina
Black
Pride,
an educational
event
at the
College
of Charleston
(SC),
and
in a
World
AIDS
Day
panel
discussion. Peers
also
report
engaging
in regular
conversations
about
HIV/AIDS
in public
venues
(e.g.
bars)
and
at parties
or other
gatherings
with
their
peers.
Recommendations
Please
see the
VIBES curriculum
for lesson
plans, and
implementation
suggestions.
Illinois
Department
of Public
Health provides
training
on this
intervention.
Where
Implemented
Midlands
of South
Carolina
Contact
Information
yeahcolumbia@gmail.com
Ryan
C. Wilson,
MEd
|
Sexually
Active Men - Condom
Use
|
Target
Behaviors
and
Behavioral
Determinants
Inconsistent
and
incorrect
condom
use
among
rural
African
American
and
Latino
men,
women,
youth,
and
MSM;
lack
of skills
to use
condoms
correctly
and
consistently;
lack
of condom
use
negotiation
skills;
lack
of social
norms
and
social
support
to promote
condom
use.
Description
VOICES/VOCES (DEBI)
VOICES/VOCES
is a
group-level
45-minute
video-based
program
that
encourages
condom
use,
and
improves
negotiation
skills.
Small
groups
of 3-8
watch
a 20-minute
video,
discuss
difficulties
experienced
trying
to use
condoms,
and
brainstorm
strategies
to increase
condom
use.
There
are
two
versions,
one
tailored
for
an African
American
audience
and
another
(bilingual)
for
a Latino
audience.
Free
condoms
are
distributed
as part
of the
program.
Adaptation
Originally
developed
and
tested
for
men
and
women
of
color
attending
STD
clinics,
this
video
has been used
in rural Florida,
Mississippi,
New York,
Ohio, Pennsylvania,
South Carolina,
Tennessee,
and Wyoming
with MSM,
rural youth
under 18,
young adults
ages 19-24,
drug users
(including
those who
inject), incarcerated
men, and in
the community
in business,
school, and
faith-based
settings.
Evidence
When
implemented
in
the
original
STD
clinic
setting,
fewer
STDs
occurred
in
the
group
that
saw
the
video
and
participated
in
the
discussion.
It
is
difficult
to
collect
evidence
of
behavior
change
for
participants
in this
single
session
intervention.
However,
in sites
that collected
post-intervention
data,
participants
are more
likely
to report
an intention
to use
condoms
consistently
after
the single
session
than before.
Recommendations
Core
elements
are
easy
to
deliver
with
fidelity
in
many
rural
settings
with
a
variety
of
audiences.
It
is
a
“great
one
time
program”
that
does
not
require
too
many
resources
and
minimal
recruitment.
Where
Implemented
Pennsylvania
Department
of Health,
Johnstown,
PA
Chattanooga CARES
Albany County Public
Health
(WY)
Duvall
County Public
Health
(FL)
Florida Community
Prevention
Center
Green
County
Public
Health
(OH)
Low
Country
Healthcare,
South
Carolina
Mississippi
State
Department
of Health
Contact
Information
Commonwealth
of Pennsylvania
Department
of Health,
Johnstown,
PA
814-533-2205
|
Rural
MSM Who Access
the Internet
|
Target
Behaviors
and
Behavioral
Determinants
Unprotected male to male sex;
sex with multiple partners linked
through Internet dating services;
lack of information and motivation
to change behavior; lack of skills
and self-efficacy to reduce risk
behaviors with Internet sex partners;
lack of social norms that support
safer sex behaviors.
Description
This
theory
guided
and
research
based
three-session
individual
Internet
intervention
uses
banners
tailored
to
different
ethnicities
to
recruit
MSM
into
the
intervention.
The
interactive
illustrated
interventions
teach
basic
information
about
HIV
transmission
and
prevention,
help
participants
rethink
how
they
can
decrease
their
specific
risk
behaviors
using
real
life
scenarios,
and
help
motivate
participants
to
change
behaviors.
The
intervention
can
be
accessed
at
www.wrapphome.net
but
active
recruitment
through
banner
placement
has
been
discontinued
at
this
time.
Evidence
Those
who
completed
the
three
sessions
report
decreased
occurrences
of
unprotected
sex,
increased
condom
use,
and
decreased
number
of
sexual
partners
(if
person
started
with
2
or
more).
The
long-term
maintenance
of
these
changes
is
not
known.
Recommendations
Tailor
messages
to cultural
values
for
each
ethnicity.
Repeated
interventions
work
better
than
one
time
interventions.
This
intervention
reaches
hidden
rural
populations
and
protects
their
anonymity
but
may
require
active
recruitment.
Where
Implemented
Wyoming
Rural
AIDS
Prevention
Project
(WRAPP)
Contact
Information
Ann
Bowen,
WRAPP, University
of Wyoming
1000 East
University
Ave, Laramie,
WY 82071
(307)
766-4327
|
|
Target
Behaviors
and
Behavioral
Determinants
Client-identified risk behaviors
include unprotected male to male
sex and drug use before and during
sex; client-identified behavioral
determinants include lack of social
networks that support safer sex
behaviors; attitudes toward safer
sex behaviors; lack of skills
and self-efficacy to negotiate
safer sex in some social situations.
Description
For
this
locally-developed
individual
level
intervention,
HIV
prevention
staff
conduct
risk
reduction
counseling
sessions
via
the
Internet,
either
in
chat
rooms
or
through
instant
messaging,
to
assist
high-risk
individuals
in
creating
brief
HIV
risk
reduction
plans,
assist
them
with
skills-building,
and
refer
them
to
HIV
testing
and
other
appropriate
prevention
services.
This
intervention
builds
on
Social
Cognitive
Theory,
Stages
of
Change, and
Diffusion
of
Innovations
Theory.
It
works
to
reach
MSM
in
rural
areas
where
services
are
scarce
and/or
distance
impedes
clients
from
accessing
services.
Evidence
This
intervention
has
not
measured
behavioral
outcomes
due
to
confidentiality
concerns.
Clients
involved
in
the
counseling
report
satisfaction
with
this
method
of
obtaining
information
and
referrals.
Recommendations
Choose
the
websites
that
community
members
log
on
to
often;
identify
the
times
of
day
that
clients
access
these
sites;
be
upfront
when
online
in
identifying
staff
as
being
from
a
health
center;
be
prepared
to
always
offer
referrals.
Ethical
issues
such
as
protecting
confidentiality
should
be
addressed
prior
to
beginning
online
counseling.
Advising
clients
of
security
limitations
and
encrypting
emails
may
be advisable.
Where
Implemented
Rural
Illinois
Contact
Information
Illinois
Department
of Public
Health
312-814-4846
|
Home
Page Ch1 Ch2 Ch
3 Ch4 Chr
5 Ch
6 Chapter
7 Ch
8
|