Setting the Environmental Scene - The Pleistocene Scene (Module 04)
Principle 6: Basic Archaeological Skills - ¯Students of archaeology must also understand the epistemological
ramifications of the discipline - how they come to know what they know about ancient peoplesê life ways . . . they
understand and interpret what they encounter under the ground.²
Discussion - The issue of the Pleistocene extinctions is a potentially contentious one and discussion of
the phenomena open the door to a whole host of ¯teachable moments.² The ¯Paul S. Martin Hypothesis²
would have a pre-human Western Hemisphere populated by a variety of Pleistocene fauna living a blissful
existence without a hint of fear of humans. Then, when Post-Pleistocene conditions give a ¯greening² light,
various groups of seasoned hunters descend through the Ice-Free Corridor, find animal prey having no
inherent fear of humans, and then begin their carnivorous rampage, leading to the ultimate complete
distinction of creatures like the mammoth, mastodon, and others. Ethologically (behaviorally), do we have
historical accounts of analogous events? The question needs to be raised because it does seem strange
that animals that formed herds (as probably was the case with the extinct probiscidians as well as with
Bison antiquus) tend to learn quickly about predatory threats, making hunting them more difficult.
What archaeological evidence do we have to support the Martin Hypothesis? What alternative explanations
do we have for the disappearance of Pleistocene fauna?
|