Review: White Laager and Generations of Resistance by Shane D. Graham
Apartheid officially ended five years ago. The Truth and Reconciliation
Commission has released its Final Report, and the amnesty hearings are
drawing to a close. It is now perhaps possible to reevaluate the history
of apartheid with some sense of closure and retrospective wisdom, so this
is an opportune time for the reissue of several of Peter Davis'
anti-apartheid documentary films from the 1970s and 1980s.
The title of the first film in the series, White Laager, refers
to the image of Afrikaner Voortrekker's closing their wagon trains to
defend against the "Black Peril" of spear-wielding "savages," an image
often used to symbolize the siege mentality of many modern Afrikaners.
Davis uses the "laager" as a framing metaphor for several important
moments in Afrikaner history, including the circled fences in the first
Dutch colony in the Cape in 1652, the literal laager at the Battle of
Blood River in 1868, the Boer War against the British at the turn of the
century, and of course the apartheid laws passed after the election of
the Afrikaner Nationalist Party in 1948. This first part of White Laager
presents the right-wing nationalists in South Africa as they see
themselves, without either demonizing or apologizing for them. The rest
of the film then systematically picks apart the inconsistencies,
contradictions, and implications of their racist and fascist beliefs.
In Generations of Resistance, Davis chooses to skip over the long
history of African resistance to white invasion throughout the eighteenth
and nineteenth centuries and begins with the "Generation of 1912,"
especially the founders of the African National Congress. The following
sections are structured around standard landmark historical events: the
"Generation of 1949" who protested against the new apartheid laws; the
"Generation of 1960," including the protestors at the Sharpeville
massacre; and the "Generation of 1976," including the school children in
the Soweto uprisings.
These films are not without their gaps. White Laager, for
instance, never reveals the identity of the Afrikaner officials and civil
servants interviewed, leaving the impression of anonymous talking heads
spouting right-wing rhetoric. But these documentaries succeed at
characterizing both sides of the struggle concisely and coherently. At
just under an hour each, these documentaries are well-suited for
classroom use, giving students who may have been in the fourth grade when
Mandela was released from prison a clear idea of what apartheid South
Africa looked like in the late 1970s.
Shane D. Graham is a doctoral candidate in English and African Studies
at Indiana University-Bloomington.
|