September11:
Before and After
**************************************

What are the Major Questions We Will Address and Who Will Address Them?

Links to Actual Readings and Weekly Assignments Can Be Found on the Password Protected Weekly Class Page.
For people who are not enrolled in the class, the readings can be found at their original sources.  Most, if not all, will be available on reserve in the Political Science Research Collection, Woodburn 200, under Prof. Barbour's name.  Where we could make it available here electronically, we did. How Did it Happen: Terrorism and the New War by Hoge and Rose is available for purchase at the bookstore.


 
Week/Date Question of the Day Lecturer Reading Assignment
1  January 7 What's this Course About and How Will It Be Run? Barbour Required:
  • Read syllabus; familiarize yourselves with September 11 Web sites. 
       January 9 How Can Political Science Help Us to Understand the Events of September 11? Barbour Required:
  • Barbour and Wright, Keeping the Republic, "Consider the Source: How to Become a Savvy Media Consumer," pp. 674-675; 
  • "Consider the Source: How to Become a Savvy Web Surfer," pp. 168-169;
  • "Consider the Source: Thinking Like a Political Scientist," pp. 22-23
 2 January 14

What is the History of Mass Killing in the 20th Century?   What are Some of the Principles of Justice by Which We Hold The Perpetrators Accountable? 

 
Bielasiak Required:
  • Human Rights Watch, Slaughter Among Neighbors. Introduction Only
      January 6 Background: What is the Colonial Legacy in the Middle East and the Emergence of the Nation-State? Harik Required:
  • Hisham Sharabi, "The Heritage of European Domination," pp. 23-42
  • Iliya Harik, "The Origins of the Arab State System," pp. 19-45
Optional:
  • Charles Smith, Palestine and the Arab-Israeli Conflict, "World War I, Great Britain, and Peace Settlements," pp. 38-67
3 January 21 MLK Birthday NO CLASS
     January 23 What Are the Middle East Internal Conflicts and the United States Involvement? Harik Required:
  • "The Persian Gulf," in Congressional Quarterly (CQ), pp. 104-129
  • "U.S. Policy in the Middle East," in CQ, pp. 64-100
Optional:
  • "The Arab Israeli Conflict," in CQ, pp. 9-60;
  • "The Persian Gulf," in CQ, pp. 101-132;
  • "U.S. Policy in themiddle East," in CQ, pp. 61-100;
  • "The Middle East: Theater of Conflict," in Global Studies; the Middle East, ed. William Spencer, pp. 16-32; 
  • Smith, Palestine and the Arab-Israeli-Conflict," pp. 124-150, 177-203, 224-231, 240-314;
  • John Haldane, "Thawing Relations with Tehran" Christian Science Monitor
4 January 28 What is Cultural Conflict, Regional and International? Harik Required:
  • Samuel Huntington, "Clash of Cultures"
  • "Islam Today: A New Assertiveness," in CQ, pp. 183-189
  • Karen Armstrong, "Was it Inevitable?  Islam through History" in Hoge and Rose, pp. 53-70. 
Optional:
  • Philip Khoury, "Islamic Revivalism and the Crisis of the Secular State in the Arab World," in I. Ibrahim, ed. Arab Resources: the Transformation of a Society **
  • "Fourteen Centuries of Islam," in CQ, pp. 169-183
     January 30 What is the History of Ethinic Conflict in Central Asia? Hale Required:
  • Rajan Menan, "The Restless Region: The Brittle States of Central and South Asia," in Hoge and Rose.
  • Fiona Hill, "Silencing Central Asia: The Voice of Dissidents." Click  here.
  • Georgi M. Derluguian, "Che Guevaras in Turbans: The Twisted Lineage of Islamic Fundamentalism in Chechnya and Dagestan," Policy Memo No.16 in the Program onNEw Approaches to Russian Security series( Wash. DC: CSIS, OCt. 1999)
5 February 4 What was the Russian Role in Afghanistan and How Did the Taliban Come to Power? Hale Required:
  • Milton Bearden, "Graveyard of Empires: Afghanistan's Treacherous Peaks," in Hoge and Rose,
  • Zamay Khalilzad and Daniel Byman, "Afghanistan: The Consolidation of a Rogue State," Washington Quarterly, Winter 2000.  Click here.
     February 6 Movie:  The Media and Democracy in the Arab World:  Behind the Scenes at Al Jezeera
6 February 11 What Was U.S. Foreign Policy in the Middle East? In Afghanistan? Spechler Review:
  • Milton Bearden, "Graveyard of Empires" in your textbook
Required:
  • Fouad Ajami, "The Uneasy Imperium: Pax Americana in the Middle East" in your textbook
  • Benjamin Soskis, "Hope in the Unseen" from the New Republic
Optional:
  • Adam Garfinkle, "The U.S. Imperial Postulate in the Mideast."
  • Gary Sick, "U.S. Policy in the Gulf: Objectives and Prospects," in Rosemary Hollis, ed., Managing New Developments in the Gulf, pp. 35-49
  • Fouad Ajami, "Stranger in the Arab-Muslim World," Wilson Quarterly
  • Fareed Zakaria, "Why Do They Hate Us?" Newsweek
     February 13 What are the Political Implications of Our Dependence on Foreign Oil? Hershey Required:
  • "'Oil Shock' to Parts of Economy Begins to Reverberate Politically"
  • "Energy and the Environment"
  • Jeff Plungis, "GOP Again Blocks Changes In Fuel Efficiency Standards"
7 February 18 What was Life Like for Women in Afghanistan Under the Taliban? Robinson Required:
  • Amy Waldman, "Behind the Burka: Women Subtly Fought Taliban," The New York Times (NYT), November 19, 2001;
  • Barbara Crossette, "Afghanistan's Women: Hope for the Future, Blunted by a Hard Past," NYT, December 2, 2001;
  • Rina Amirii, "Muslim Women as Symbols - and Pawns," NYT, November 27, 2001;
  • John Schulz and Linda Schulz, "The Darkest of Ages: Afghan Women Under the Taliban," Peace and Conflict 1999 5 (3)
     February 20 What are the Politics of a Global Economy? Hart Required:
  • "Unlocal & Afghanistan"
  • "Afghanistan"
  • "Afghanistan - Needed for Oil & Gas Pipelines"
  • Joan Spero & Jeff Hart, "Oil, Commodity Cartels, and Power"
  • Anatol Lieven, "The True Significance of the Attacks," in your textbook
  • Fareed Zakaria, "What September 11 Hath Wrought," in your textbook
8 February 25 Movie:  Why the Hate?
America From a Muslim Point of View
     February 27 How Could Anyone Do That? McGinnis Review:
  • Fouad Ajami, "Pax Americana in the Middle East," in your textbook


Required:

  • Nasra Hassan, "An Arsenal of Believers," The New Yorker, November 19, 2001.
  • Samuel Berger and Mona Sutphen, "Bin Laden's Belated Concern," in your textbook
  • Walter Laqueur, "The Changing Face of Terror," in your textbook
  • Michael Doran, "Ideology, Rage, and the Assault on America," in your textbook
  • Ehud Sprinzak, "Rational Fanatics," in Foreign Policy
  • Bernard Lewis, "License to Kill,' in Foreign Affairs
9 March 4 What Was Our World Like on September 12? Barbour TBA
     March 6 What Did the Public Think, and Why Does that Matter? Wright
  • Barbara Bardes, “Public Opinion and Foreign Policy: How Does the Public Think About America’s Role in the World?" 
  • Barbour and Wright, Excerpt on “The Presidency and Public Opinion” from Chap. 8 of Keeping the Republic.
  • Alan Wolf “American Society Responds to the New War” pp. 283-294 in your textbook.
  • Powell, "Across America, Voices of Support," 
  • Morin and Milbank, "Bush and GOP enjoy Record Popularity.
10 March 11 SPRING BREAK NO CLASS
     March 13 Have Fun!  Be Safe! NO CLASS
11 March 18 What Was the American Dipolomatic and Military Response to the Attacks? Spechler Review:
  • Rajan Menan, "The Restless Region," in your textbook
Required:
  • F. Gregory Gause III, "The Kingdom in the Middle: Saudi Arabia's Double Game," in Hoge and Rose
  • Wesley K. Clark, "Waging the New War: What's Next for America's Armed Forces?" in Hoge and Rose
  • Michael Mandelbaum, "Diplomacy in Wartime: New Priorities and Alignments," in your textbook
  • Tom Grant, "Bin Laden's Grand Miscalcluation"
Optional:
  • Chistopher de Bellaigue, "The Perils of Pakistan," The New York Review of Books
  • Michael Rubin, "Uncivil," The New Republic
  • Joshua Teitelbaum, "Deserted," The New Republic
  • Samuel Berger and Mon Sutphen, "Commandeering the Palestinian Cause: Bin Laden's Belated Concern," in Hoge and Rose
  • William Wechsler, "Strangling the Hydra: Targeting Al Qaeda's Finances," in Hoge and Rose
     March 20 Video and Discussion of the Benton Murals Barbour
  • No reading. Think about what kinds of things would make you feel uncomfortable if someone put them on the wall of a classroom where you were required to attend class.
12 March 25 Can a Democracy Defend Itself at Home? McGinnis Required:
     March 27 What Are the Longer-Term Domestic Political Consequences of September 11 or, Whatever Happened to Checks and Balances? Wright Required:
  • Alexis Simendinger, "Power of One"   and 
  • Carl Cannon, "Fighting on Two Fronts"  both from National Journal, January 26, 2002. 
13 April 1 Checks and Balances, cont'd Wright See above.
     April 3 What's the Role of the Media During Wartime? Barbour
  • "In Review: Framing the Flag" and
  • Neil Hickey, "Access Denied: The Pentagon's War Reporting Rules are the Toughest Ever" Columbia Journalism Review March/April 2002.
  • Frank Rich, "Freedom from the Press,: The New York Times, March 2, 2002.
14 April 8 What's our History of Racial Profiling When We are in National Crisis (And When We Aren't)? Alex-Assensoh Required:
  • Ronald Takaki, A Different Mirror: A History of Multicultural America, Chapter 1 (pp. 1-17) and Chapter 14 (pp. 378-401)
     April 10 What Happens to Our Civil Liberties in Wartime? Isaac Required:
  • Randolph Bourne, "The State"
  • U.S. Supreme Court Schenck v. U.S., 249 U.S. 47
15 April 15 Civil Liberties Continued Isaac Required:
  • U.S.A. Patriot Act (H.R. 132)
  • White House Executive Order on Military Tribunals
  • Jeffrey Isaac, "Supporting the War"
  • Jeffrey Isaac, "Why Democracy Matters Now"
  • Jacob Weisberg, "Taking Liberties"
  • William Safire, "Voices of Negativism"
  • Jeffrey Rosen, "Holding Pattern"
  • Laurence H. Tribe, "Trial by Fury"
  • Bruce Shapiro, "Alien's Law"
  • David Cole, "National Security State"
April 17 What Does it Mean to Love One's Country? Craiutu Required:
  • Martha Nussbaum, "Patriotism and Cosmopolitanism," in For Love of Country: Debating the Limits of Patriotism, eds. Martha Nussbaum and Joshua Cohen
  • Alexis de Tocqueville, "Public Spirit in the US," pages 235-237 in Democracy in America
 
April 19
**Friday**
Terrorism and the Relationship between the
President and Congress
Former Congressman Lee Hamilton
16 April 22 Is this a Just War? Failer Required:
  • Michael Walzer, "Excusing Terror: The Politics of Ideological Apology," American Prospect
Optional:
  • Michael Walzer, Just and Unjust Wars
     April 24 Where Do We Go From Here? Barbour TBA