This material may be copied only for noncommercial classroom teaching purposes, and only if this source is clearly cited.
|SEE “Chromosome Connections: Compelling Clues to Common Ancestry”
Article by Larry Flammer published in the American Biology Teacher (NABT journal, February 2013).
Students compare banding patterns on hominid (human and ape) chromosomes, and see striking evidence of their common ancestry. Additional comparisons test (and confirm) that common ancestry hypothesis. Students find the “molecular fossil” of telomere fusion in our cells. This engaging inquiry demonstrates the power of multiple lines of evidence.
|NOTICE: A new version of this lesson has been added, called "The Mystery of the Missing Marks." It consists of a PowerPoint program that walks students through the problem-solving process for testing the hypothesis that our #2 chromosome resulted from the fusion of two shorter chromosomes found in chimps. Students search for the telomere DNA in the middle of our #2 chromosome, and FIND it, a real molecular fossil that we all have. This version provides the DNA segment containing the telomere DNA, so there is no need for students to search online databases (preferred, but also a litle tricky and time consuming. Directions for doing that are contained in this Chromosome Fusion lesson).|
|The banding pattern of our long chromosome #2 closely matches the banding patterns of two shorter chromosomes found in apes. This suggests the likelihood that our #2 chromosome was formed by the head-to-head fusion (merging) of those two shorter chromosomes in an early human ancestor. To test that hypothesis, students search for evidence of this fusion in the DNA of chromosome #2, using online databases (or printouts of same) to seek the sequences typical of terminal DNA (telomeres). In the process, students see how patterns can reveal events of the past, thereby merging elements of both experimental and historical science. They discover the huge amount of DNA in a chromosome, get a sense of gene size and the number of pseudogenes, correlate visible chromosome bands and their contained DNA, and learn to use an accessible online resource for further study and inquiry. In the end, they come to realize that each of us carries copies of that "molecular fossil" - the remains of telomere fusion in our #2 chromosome - in nearly every cell in our bodies.|
|Modern apes and humans evolved from a common ancestor.|
|1. The evidence that humans have evolved from
non-humans is stronger than that for evolution within most other
2. Many features of modern organisms reflect the structure of their ancestors in ways that are not adaptive.
3. Scientific explanations confirmed by different lines of evidence are stronger, more likely to be accurate.
4. DNA provides a useful record and diagnostic tool to study the ancestry of modern organisms.
5. Hypotheses about past events can be tested by looking for revealing patterns in the present.
6. Genes and pseudogenes are directly accessible on the internet for study and inquiry.
1. Given the likely fusion area sequence, students will recognize
a) the telomere region from one original chromosome
b) the telomere region from the other original chromosome
c) the precise point of fusion (where the telomeres from two chromosomes meet head-to-head)
2. Students will correctly explain the significance of this fusion (in context with other indicators: molecular, banding patterns, fossil comparisons) in terms of biological relationship between apes and humans.
3. Students will demonstrate ability to navigate one of two websites to display the DNA sequence of a desired region in a selected chromosome.
Student Handouts (see below)
ALL MATERIALS ARE IN PDF FILES TO RETAIN THEIR CRITICAL FORMAT. SEE END OF LESSON FOR INFORMATION ON READING PDF FILES.
|Two 45 minute class periods (or one period, with tightly structured, guided discussion by teacher).|
Click on items underlined
below to download those PDF files.
NOTICE: Part C has been omitted; Online interface for this part no longer working.
WHY YOUR STUDENTS SHOULD DO THIS
2. Connects the visible (chromosome banding) with the abstract (molecular structure of DNA)
3. Students USE same online tools that scientists use to do bioinformatics, e.g., BLAST and online database.
4. Students SEE the amount of DNA in a tiny segment of DNA in a chromosome.
5. Students discover compelling evidence of our common ancestry with apes.
OPTIONAL PATHWAYS: At first glance, this lesson may seem
complicated and time-consuming. However, there are four different
ways your students can do this lesson, four different pathways
following the Observations, Questions, and Possible Explanations
2. More Time, Using "BLAST" Search Tool: Students do Parts A & B (online visual search, followed by a computer search with "Blast", with detailed instructions and check-questions along the way.
3. Teacher Demo: Teacher uses overhead to walk class through Part D, OR uses projector with online computer to walk class through Parts A and/or B. Any of these pathways could use the PowerPoint presentation described below to introduce the lesson.
4. Homework Assignment: Students can be asked to do one or two specified parts at home (or on their own time), or it can be offered as an extra credit assignment. Each part is self-instructive.
NEW PowerPoint Presentation for this lesson (Chromosome Fusion?) is now available. This makes a very helpful introuction to the lesson, or could even be used instead of the lesson if time is short (not as good as students doing it themselves, though!) The PPP is presented as an inquiry approach (as is the lesson), and includes results with discussion items. Be sure to use the Script provided with this PowerPoint.
2. Provide sufficient copies of the Figures (one set per team, ideally placed back-to-back in plastic sleeves or laminated for easy re-use).
3. Overhead transparencies (or PowerPoint slides) could be made of Figures 1-5 (plus the Intro Figure) to illustrate a classroom discussion of the process. If you intend to walk your class through the Challenge and DNA Details, you should also have overhead transparencies (or slides) of the DNA diagram pages. Additional illustrations desired from specific DNA website pages will be emailed to you if you request them from the ENSI webmaster.
4. DNA Models,
showing the 5' - 3' distinctions. These would be helpful to show
students why the 5' end of one DNA strand can only attach to
the 3' end of the DNA strand in the other chromosoeme. One of
the best models to show this is the Molymod DNA model. It's detailed
enough to convey the essential structure of DNA clearly, with
appropriate molecular shapes, yet it doesn't show every atom
in the molecule. It's also large and colorful enough to be seen
fairly well. The Molymod kit listed below will make two DNA molecules
(showing the tandem repeats), each about 10 cm by 29 cm. It's
even more impressive if you can insert the DNA models of the
tandem repeats into the ends of a couple lengths (3' - 4') of
4" white flexible dryrer vent duct tubing, marked with black
felt pen to mimic the banding patterns of the two short chromosomes
in chimps (2a and 2b) that clearly fused to form our #2.
Below are suitable models from 3 vendors (prices as of Sept. 2006):
Carolina Biological Supply:
Ward's Natural Science:
1. INTRODUCTION (Read this to students):
2. If students haven't seen (in an earlier lesson on chromosome
comparisons) the page showing the banding patterns for all
the chromosomes of humans and apes, be sure to show this
to them (Intro Figure), either in a handout, or on
your overhead projector. Tell them that these are banding pattern
diagrams of the chromosomes from 4 different species of animals.
Ask them what they see as most striking about the page... what
stands out? [Hopefully, they will notice the strong similarities
in banding patterns between the species]. Then point out that
the first chromosome in each set is human, the second is from
a chimp, the third is from a gorilla, and the fourth is from
5. Be sure to emphasize that the telomere-fusion region that they have found is essentially a "molecular fossil" - the remains of an avent that happened some 3 million years ago in the hominin line somwhat after branching off from the chimpanzee line. And each of us posesses copies of that fossil in nearly every cell in our bodies.
6. It may help students to understand the 5' to 3' union requirement for fusion if you use a DNA model (see pics).
ATTENTION: Sometimes, websites make changes. If you or your students find that the website pages don't seem to fit or respond to the descriptions in our directions, possibly, you (or clever students) can adapt to the changes and figure out how to accomplish the essential tasks critical to this lesson. ENSI has no control over the changes in other websites. In any case, let the ENSI webmaster know, and the directions will be revised to fit the changes and uploaded to the ENSI website. You will be notified when this has been done. A case in point: during the development of this lesson, the Sanger site made major changes to its pages, requiring major revisions to our directions. It does happen! Then Sanger did it again, making it impossible to find the colorful image of the telomere fusion area. So Part C was omitted.
|[sample assessments, questions, are welcome, based on the Assessable Objectives (above); please send to ENSI webmaster to share on site]|
1. A challenging extension would be for students to seek the DNA sequences at the ends of chromosomes, to confirm that they indeed show the same tandem repeats for telomeres as indicated in the existing lesson. In fact, if time allows, this could be an interesting "discovery" activity to precede this "Chromosome Fusion" lesson. However, be forewarned that the downstream telomeres (at the lower ends of the q arms) lack around 100-200,000 basepairs due to the lack of contigs for those ends.
2. Another easy extension (added 6/15/2006) involves the search for evidence of the second (upper) centromere. In the process, students experience examples of Fair Tests and MILEs (Multiple Independent Lines of Evidence). Click Here for a little worksheet that does this, and refers to a News Release that reports on that second centromere.
3. Experience with this lesson could encourage students to explore other lessons that utilize online DNA and protein analyzing programs, e.g., the Tutorial: Investigating Evolutionary Questions, Using Online Molecular Databases and Pseudogenes, Vitamin C & Common Ancestry. These programs will further enrich student understanding of evolution and the nature of science, and the role of DNA analysis in helping to do this.
4. OTHER LESSONS: If not already studied, students
should also work with the following lessons on this site, providing
Multiple Independent Lines of Evidence deeply reinforcing
the concept that humans and apes share a common ancestry:
The Mystery of the Missing Marks (this is largely a PowerPoint presentation, and could be done in place of the Chromosome Fusion lesson - but with less hands-on experience.
Comparison of Hominid Chromosomes (this, or the Chromosome Connection lesson should precede the Chromosome Fusion lesson).
Chromosome Connection (at www.becominghuman.org > Learning Center > Lesson Plans)
Chromosome Connection 2 (revised, improved version, on site)
Hominid Cranial Comparisons (Skulls Lab)
Molecular Sequences & Primate Evolution
Footsteps in Time: the Laetoli Trackway
NOTE: NEW PRIMATE TAXONOMY - Due to molecular and genetic studies, the African apes are now placed in the same family (hominids) as humans, and humans have been moved into the subfamily "hominins". Click here for details of this revised taxonomy.
"Comparison of the Human and Great Ape Chromosomes as Evidence for Common Ancestry" by Robert Williams, from The Evolution Evidence Page at http://www.gate.net/~rwms/EvoEvidence.html
You will find additional, very useful references on that page,
"Gene Content and Function of the Ancestral Chromosome Fusion Site in Human Chromosome 2q13-2q14.1 and Paralogous Regions" by Yuxin Fan, Tera Newman, Elena Linardopoulou, and Barbara Trask. Genome Research, 2002 Nov., 12(11): 1663-72
Chromosomal Speciation Models: ENSI Co-Director, Craig E. Nelson responds to ENSI-using teachers' questions about "How does the first chromosome change get passed along to future generations?" Explanations and resources are offered.
Also, see the engaging reading-worksheet assignment: Chromosome Shuffle - possibly assign as homework before doing the Chromosome Fusion lesson.
Some of the ideas in this lesson may have been adapted from earlier, unacknowledged sources without our knowledge. If the reader believes this to be the case, please let us know, and appropriate corrections will be made. Thanks.
This lesson was developed in July, 2005 by Larry Flammer, ENSI webmaster. It was inspired by the Evolution Evidence Page by Robert Williams (see Resources above).
Many thanks to scientists Yuxin Fan and Barbara Trask (authors of referenced article) for their generous help in accessing the fusion regions online, and doing a Blast search.
Also, thanks to Kevin Flammer and Steven Flammer for beta testing an early draft. Their suggestions were very valuable, leading to a complete re-write of the lesson.
Major Adjustments made Sep 2015 by L. Flammer
The following is an HTML version of the Student Handout, without the Figures. These are all available in PDF format from the list of MATERIALS above.
2. Notice the identical banding patterns between the corresponding arms of the human (Hu) and the two chimpanzee (Ch) chromosomes. Our "p" arm is nearly identical to the chimp's upper chromosome, and our "q" arm is nearly identical to the chimp's lower chromosome.
3. Look carefully at the region near the middle of our chromosome 2 that corresponds to where the tip ends of the two matching chimp chromosomes overlap and where the bands are not identical to those in our chromosome 2. Do you see the white band located there, labeled 2q13?
B. INTERESTING QUESTION: Why does our chromosome #2 appear to be so very similar to the two shorter chromosomes found in apes (chimpanzees, gorillas, and orangutans)?
C. SOME POSSIBLE EXPLANATIONS (Building a Working Hypothesis):
To suggest "design" as an explanation usually implies a supernatural designer, and since supernatural forces cannot be reliably tested or disproved (basic requirement for all scientific explanations), "design" cannot be properly considered as a scientific explanation.
Other studies (fossil and molecular) have suggested that the gorillas and orangutans apparently branched off (from an evolutionary line leading to humans) earlier than when the chimps branched off. So explanation #2 (above, identical fissions) would have been required to happen 3 times independently, and this is very unlikely.
That leaves explanation #3, namely that human chromosome #2 probably resulted from the head-to-head fusion (joining) of those two smaller chromosomes in an early human ancestor after the apes branched off. This is the hypothesis that we will be testing. We will want to look for evidence of that ancestral fusion in our current chromosome #2.
D. DNA DETAILS DETOUR: If you are unfamiliar with details of chromosome orientation, chromosome telomeres, telomere structure (and variations), 5'-3' and 3'-5' orientations of the parallel strands of a DNA molecule, and the only way two DNA molecules can join, study the DNA DETAILS beginning on page 3, then return to this point to continue.
E. PREDICTION: If fusion happened, there should be evidence of the two telomeres from the two ancestral chromosomes in that apparent fusion region (2q13) near the middle of our chromosome #2. If we can find the DNA sequences of two sets of head-to-head telomeres in the suspected fusion region, this would provide strong evidence that our chromosome #2 was indeed formed from the head-to-head fusion of two shorter chromosomes from our earlier ancestry (the same two chromosomes we find separately today in the apes). The existence of head-to-head telomeres mid-chromosome would otherwise be hard to explain. This evidence further strongly confirms a close kinship of humans and apes.
F. THE TEST: To test our selected hypothesis, you will need to search the suspected fusion region in chromosome 2 for evidence of head-to-head telomeres. If that evidence is found, our hypothesis is strengthened. If evidence is not found, the hypothesis may not be correct.
II. THE SEARCH
IF YOU DO NOT HAVE INTERNET ACCESS: Do Part D. You will need to get copies of all the Figures, along with a copy of Part D directions.
PART A. VISUAL SEARCH ONLINE with NCBI
PART B. SEARCH WITH the "BLAST2" SEARCH TOOL
PART C. SEARCH on the SANGER GENOME BROWSER
PART D. PAPER SEARCH on the ONE-PAGE COPY OF DNA in the
2. Since each letter in strand 2 can be inferred (and assumed)
from its matching letter in strand 1, we often just work with
one strand to keep it simpler and take less space, as shown below:
However, each letter (base) in strand 1 may still be called a "base-pair" (bp), reflecting the fact that it represents a matched pair of bases at that position in the complete DNA molecule.
3. By the way, do you see the repeating pattern in that sequence?
If not, try saying the letters in that sequence out loud. You
should see that the sequence ttaggg repeats over and over again.
These are called "tandem repeats." In order to clarify
this pattern, we can insert a break between each set (although,
in reality, there are no breaks), so strand 1 would look like
4. In reality, these sequences may vary slightly, especially
as the telomere region comes closer to the non-telomere DNA.
For example, part of the sequence might look like this:
6. Chromosomes in a karyotype (total chromosome array for a species) are typically oriented with their centromeres above the midpoint of each chromosome (somewhere between the midpoint and the end of the shortest arm, which we call the "p" arm); see the Introductory Figure, showing the karyotypes of humans (properly oriented) and 3 ape species, side by side for each corresponding chromosome, oriented to show closest matching. The uppermost end of each human chromosome (with the shorter, or p, arm) is called the "head end."
7. The single DNA molecule in each chromosome is, of course, composed of two parallel strands, held together by the hydrogen bonds between its matching base pairs. Something you may or may not have learned is that one strand is oriented upside down relative to the other. The deoxyribose sugars in both strands are comprised of carbon atoms numbered from one to five. See Figure 5. When the number 5 carbon attaches to the phosphate group above it, and the number 3 carbon connects to the phosphate below it, we say that it is oriented 5' to 3' (5 prime to 3 prime). This is the orientation of strand 1. Its companion strand (strand 2), is oriented oppositely: 3' to 5'. The matching bases require this opposing orientation in order to bond properly to each other, holding the two strands together.
8. When you look at the two chimpanzee chromosomes that match our chromosome #2, notice (in Fig. 1) that the upper chimp chromosome (we'll call it the "p" chromosome) is "upside down" (its centromere is near its lower end), and the lower chimp chromosome ("q" chromosome) is "right side up" (its centromere is near its upper end). Therefore, if those two chromosomes joined together to make our chromosome #2, they must have joined "head to head." Study Fig. 1 carefully to verify that.
9. However, it's important to note that strand 1 in the head
end of the upper (p) chromosome (the 5' end) cannot
join with strand 1 in the head end of the lower (q) chromosome
(also its 5' end). Due to their structural chemistry, a 5' end
cannot join with another 5' end:
Fusion can't happen here: the two 5' ends can't join each other, and neither can the two 3' ends.
10. But, with a half twist, the 5' end will meet and join the 3' end in the other chromosome, and likewise for the other two strands:
A useful analogy could be the way 4 rectangular magnets would behave. Color the North poles of each magnet red (=5'), and the South poles blue (=3'). When two are brought side-by-side, red and blue ends are attracted. When the two pairs are now brought end-to-end, each red end (5') attracts a blue end (3').
11. When those telomere ends join together, we see the following.
In your notebook, complete the diagram by showing the missing
letters that would be on the line (do not write on this sheet):
12. Looking at just one strand again, for simplicity, this
is how the 5' head end of the upper (p) chromosome, when fused
to the 3' head end of the lower (q) chromosome, would appear:
13. Using the slightly modified sequences (more typical),
the fusion point can also look like this:
All materials are in Adobe Acrobat pdf format in order to maintain their intended layout (see Materials). To access all pages (for printing and copying), you will need to download the free Acrobat Reader from Adobe (unless it's already installed in your system).