© 2003 ENSI (Evolution & the Nature of Science Institutes) www.indiana.edu/~ensiweb
This material may be copied only for noncommercial classroom teaching purposes, and only if this source is clearly cited.

 Return to List of Lessons

 Return Home

Date a Rock!

An Age-Dating Simulation
by Karen Kalumuck
Biology Education Director at the San Francisco Exploratorium
Variation and Adaptation for ENSIWEB by Larry Flammer
Click here for PDF of this lesson

 

EVOLUTION

 

Time
 NOTICE: If a student ever challenges you with criticisms of the reliability or validity of geological age-dating methods, CLICK HERE

 SYNOPSIS

Students get simulated "rock samples" which show a "highly magnified" selection of 128 atoms, each sample with a different proportion of the atoms of two different elements: a parent radioisotope, and its daughter product. By counting the parent radioactive atoms and knowing the "half-life" of those atoms, students can figure the number of half-lives since the sample solidified, and therefore the "age" of the sample.

 PRINCIPAL CONCEPT

Age-dating rocks involves counting atoms and comparing the counts.

 ASSOCIATED CONCEPT

Radioisotope half-lives provide a reliable measure for age-dating rocks.

ASSESSABLE OBJECTIVES

   Students will....

1. recognize what is measured in determining elapsed time in geological samples.
2. know that half-life is a measure of the rate of decay of radioisotopes.
3. know that radioactive decay involves atoms changing to different atoms.

 MATERIALS

- Ziplock bags containing various ratios of two different items (e.g. beans and popcorn seeds)
- Overhead showing those different ratios identified for each bag, and the half-life and age for each "bag"
- Geological map (colored, on wall or overhead)
- Some fossils, with known (or estimated) ages

 TIME

One 45 minute class period
STUDENT HANDOUTS No printed handouts.

 

 

TEACHING STRATEGY

CONTEXT/BACKGROUND
This lesson would fit well into any Earth Science or Geology class. It would also be useful in any science class in which radioactivity and/or geological age-dating, time-scales or fossils are encountered (Physical Science, Physics, Chemistry, or Biology). This lesson would probably fit best whenever the ages of fossils or rocks have been encountered, enabling students to readily understand the essentials for how they are dated. Although it could just be a stand-alone lesson, it was intended to introduce our Deep Time lesson, laying the background for doing the isotope sequencing activity (#15) in that lesson, then the Deep Time packet and worksheet which can be finished as a homework assignment.

PREPARATION
18 Ziplock bags (snack or lunch size)
bag of small beans, e.g. pinto
bag of popcorn kernels (not popped!)

Set up a set of 9 bags, labeled with marker pen "A ­ I", and 9 more labeled the same (or "J ­R")
Place the numbers of beans (Be) and popcorn seeds (Co) into each bag as shown below:
(TIP: count out 50 popcorn seeds into a 10 ml graduated cylinder, note the "volume", and simply fill to volume to get approximate multiples of the popcorn numbers; much easier than counting!)

DATE A ROCK
Beanium ---> Cornium
Half Life = 100 million years

 SAMPLE  SAMPLE  Be  Co  Half-Lives  Mil. Yrs
 128    
 K  B  64 64     
 L  32 96    
 M  16  112    
 E  8  120    
 F  4  124    
 G  2 126     
 H  1  127    
R  I  0  128    

Have available the following items:
Overhead transparencies of: the Date a Rock table (PDF, enlarged); the Deep Time Isotopes sequence sheet
A few recognizable fossils, of known (or approximately known) age. Good sources: a local university geology department, or your science supply house.
A colorful geological map, preferably of your area (on wall, or as an overhead color transparency). Good sources: the USGS online, or your science supply house.
The Deep Time activity envelopes (one for each team of two, with isotope strips in them)
The Deep Time handouts: 6-page packets, and the worksheets.
The pre- and post-test quizzes, ready to hand out (optional)
A scaled time-line for the solar system around the classroom, if possible (see our Time Machine lesson).

 

 

PROCEDURES

PRESENTATION OUTLINE (See Script of a sample dialogue for this lesson, in PDF format)
1. ENGAGE: Show geological maps, timelines, and/or fossils, pointing out ages in millions of years, asking "How do we know these ages? How sure are we about these ages? How do we measure the ages of rocks?"
2. EXPLORE:
a. Count "atoms" in simulated rock samples of different "ages". Students relate half-lives of radioisotopes to the application of dating rocks.
b. Sequence all known radioisotopes with half-lives greater than 1 million years; look for pattern, showing that all longer-lived isotopes are still with us, and the shorter-lived ones are not, indicating a finite age of our solar system, and that its age must be in the millions or billions of years.
3. EXPLAIN: Do the Deep Time lesson, which emphasizes why we are so confident of geological age dates.
4. ELABORATE: Do the Virtual Age Dating Tutorial (online), for further reinforcing of half-life concept and how this is applied to dating rocks. This is especially helpful in explaining how isochrones work, and why they are so compelling.
5. EVALUATE: Pre/Post test to sample understanding of material.

ASSESSMENT

Try the pre- and post-tests (a 10-item multiple choice quiz provided), or create your own.

EXTENSIONS

& VARIATIONS   

1. Consider using other items to replace the beans and popcorn. Beans can break. The original version used peanuts in their shells (Peanutium-128) and M&Ms (Emenemium-128) in large Ziplock bags. Also consider permanently sealing each set in its plastic bag, if you have such a device.

2. If you have a fair number of math-literate students, consider providing a number of bags ("rock samples") with ratios other than precise half-life proportions, and have class create a half-life curve and figure out the age of their particular samples according to where they fit on the curve.

3. Encourage (or even facilitate) students to do the online Virtual Age Dating Tutorial, using a high speed internet connection, with the prospect of earning their official "Certificates of Completion as a Virtual Geochronologist".

4. Consider taking your students on a simulated journey back in time in our Time Machine. It's an experience they'll never forget (well, maybe in time)

5. Be sure to display a scaled geological time in your room throughout the year, something you can use repeatedly, helping your students to internalize the relative timing for events occurring in geological history. See the Time Machine lesson for specifics.

 ATTRIBUTION

Some of the ideas in this lesson may have been adapted from earlier, unacknowledged sources without our knowledge. If the reader believes this to be the case, please let us know, and appropriate corrections will be made. Thanks.

1. Original Source: The original version (using peanuts and M&Ms) was done at the San Francisco Exploratorium by its Biology Education Director Karen Kalumuck in her Evolution Teaching Workshop, 11/23/2002.

2. Modified by: Larry Flammer, April, 2003, and successfully tested on classes of Earth Science students.


 

Return to Top of Page

 Home

 Return to List of Lessons