Phaik Yin

You are a junior high school science teacher. Besides native speakers of English in your class, you have second language learners as well. One of them was a student from Taiwan, named Phaik Yin. You were very excited initially to have her because she was an honor student from her junior high school in Taiwan and you have heard from her language teachers about her diligence and hard work. Her parents also told you in a meeting, that Phaik Yin had won several merit awards in science. However, in your class, Phaik Yin is not showing much progress at all. In fact, she was often depressed and her state of mind is affecting the morale of the whole class and most particularly the other second language learners. You suspect the problem is with language but reports have shown that Phaik Yin and the other second language learners in your class have done well enough so as not to need extra language classes. When you talk to Phaik Yin, she says she does not understand most of the time and reports that her friends who speak English as a Second Language in the classroom are in the same position. You are puzzled because all of the L2 students seem to be communicatively proficient in English and their writing are comprehensible and well-structured. You decide to consult your ENL colleagues for advice and suggestions on how to conduct your classes.