Go to Science@NASA home page

Earth rocks on the Moon

Astrobiologists speculate that a valuable record of Earth's distant past is preserved on the Moon.




Oct. 18, 2002: People worry a lot about asteroids. Although the odds of Earth being hit by a big one are slim, the consequences are terrifying: tsunamis, climate change, even mass extinction. Fortunately, it doesn't happen often.

Four billion years ago it happened all the time. Our planet was still young and the inner solar system was littered with asteroid-sized "planetesimals," the leftover building blocks of planets. Planetesimals, some big and some small, hit Earth every single day. This so-called "Period of Heavy Bombardment" (or PHB) lasted from about 4.5 to 3.8 billion years ago--a span that couldn't have been pleasant for terrestrial life.

See Explanation.  Clicking on the picture will download
 the highest resolution version available.

Above: Planetesimals littered the solar system when Earth was still a young planet.

Earth's early pounding was one of the topics discussed this month when experts and students from around the world met at "Perspectives in Astrobiology," a NATO Advanced Studies Institute in Chania, Crete, sponsored jointly by NATO and the Marshall Space Flight Center. Science@NASA's Ron Koczor was there, and this is his report:

Participants at the meeting noted something odd about the end of the Period of Heavy Bombardment. From the earliest geologic records known (roughly 3.8 billion years old), there is fossil evidence indicating life on Earth. The existence of apparently successful microbial life so soon after the end of these cataclysmic bombardments suggests that life emerged on Earth during the violent PHB itself.

How could that happen? Did comets or asteroids deliver life intact to Earth? Maybe life rapidly evolved from organic building blocks deposited by comets. No one knows. Astrobiologists would love to study rocks and chemical fossils from that epoch, yet because of Earth's wind, rain, earthquakes and plate tectonics (normal environmental processes), the record has been completely erased.

Or has it?

Scientists at the conference speculated that such a record does exist. Not on Earth, but on the Moon.

See Explanation.  Clicking on the picture will download 
 the highest resolution version available.

Left: The Moon is scarred with ancient meteorite impacts that, on Earth, would have long ago weathered away.

When a large body strikes Earth, impact debris can be accelerated to orbital speed and achieve Earth orbit. Four billion years ago Earth was probably surrounded by debris ejected in this way. (The Moon itself is a big piece of Earth that sundered when a Mars-sized planetestimal hit 4.5 billion years ago.) During the Period of Heavy Bombardment, the Moon was considerably closer to the Earth than it is now, perhaps 3 times closer. This placed the Moon in an ideal position to sweep up some of the terrestrial debris.

Because the Moon lacks weather or tectonic activity, that debris might still be there. While some has undoubtedly been destroyed by subsequent impacts of asteroids or comets on the Moon, some might have survived in the lunar soil. A recent study by Univ. of Washington graduate students John Armstrong and Llyd Wells, in collaboration with Guillermo Gonzalez at Iowa State, suggests that as much as 20,000 kg of Earth material could cover every 100 square kilometers of the moon.

David McKay, an astrobiologist at NASA's Johnson Space Center, notes that "the Moon was in a unique position to be a collector of ejecta from Earth. If we look in the right places, we could find a reservoir of materials for study."

Right: Apollo 16 astronaut Charles Duke collects rock samples near Plumb crater on the Moon.

see captionThe 400 kg or so of lunar rocks and soils already on the Earth thanks to Apollo begs the question: Have such terrestrial materials been seen in any of the returned samples? According to McKay: no. "I know of no reports of such materials, but I think the reason may be that no one has actually looked for them! This is an emerging area of research that was not considered over the past 30 years since Apollo."

Where should future astronauts look on the Moon for these ejected terrestrial materials? There are several possibilities.

One place, according to John Armstrong, would be the Moon's eastern (as seen from Earth) limb. "The Moon's rotation about its axis is synchronized with its revolution around the Earth," explains Armstrong. This means that the same side of the Moon--its eastern limb--is always the leading edge as it circles Earth. That leading edge would tend to sweep up more orbiting debris than other areas.

"This is true for materials that are ejected into high Earth orbit. Another possibility is that material is ejected and travels directly from Earth to the Moon. In that case, it would be found anywhere on the Earth-facing side," said Armstrong. A third possibility is that the Earth material is ejected into a longer-lasting solar orbit. In this case the material could have spent thousands or millions of years in orbit and then impacted the Moon in a more random pattern.

Below: Moon rocks ejected by asteroid impacts have landed on Earth (the reverse of the process described in this article). This one was found in Antarctica.

see captionHow could we distinguish an ancient Earth rock from a genuine Moon rock? After all, the Moon itself is a very old piece of Earth.

According to Armstrong, that question is still under discussion. "There are several possible chemical differences," he says. One would be water. Earth's oceans formed after the Moon split off from our planet. While Moon rocks are dry, some Earth rocks contain hydrated minerals--those which have water incorporated into their molecular structure. Other differences could be the presence of hydrocarbons or carbonates.

Perhaps a series of lunar missions would find such rocks: "We could develop automated robotic techniques that scan thousands or millions of small rocks, searching for Earth materials in lunar soils," speculates McKay. "It would be like looking for a needle in a haystack--a task that would be nearly impossible if done by hand but easily done by robots. We simply need to know which properties are the most useful for distinguishing Earth materials from Moon materials and set the robotic instruments to sniff them out."

It is often said that traveling makes you appreciate home that much more. In this case, traveling to the Moon may be the only way we can ever understand the early chaotic period of Earth's formation.


Credits & Contacts
Author: Ron Koczor
Responsible NASA official: Ron Koczor
Production Editor: Dr. Tony Phillips
Curator: Bryan Walls
Media Relations: Steve Roy
The Science Directorate at NASA's Marshall Space Flight Center sponsors the Science@NASA web sites. The mission of Science@NASA is to help the public understand how exciting NASA research is and to help NASA scientists fulfill their outreach responsibilities.


More information
Perspectives in Astrobiology -- a NATO Advanced Studies Institute in Chania, Crete, sponsored jointly by NATO and the Marshall Space Flight Center.

Evidence that life began soon after the Period of Heavy Bombardment: Life under Bombardment (Astrobiology Magazine); 13C-Depleted Carbon Microparticles in >3700-Ma Sea-Floor Sedimentary Rocks from West Greenland (Science); Earth's Oldest Mineral Grains Suggest an Early Start for Life (NAI)

see captionLunar Meteorites -- The process described in this story works in reverse, too. Moon rocks liberated by lunar impacts can land on Earth. See also Meteorites from the Moon (JSC)

Robotic Antarctic Meteorite Search -- Like the robots McKay suggested might one day scour the Moon for Earth-rocks, the robot "NOMAD" has searched Antarctica for Moon- and Mars-rocks.

Right: An artist's concept of NOMAD in Antarctica. [more]

Sweet Meteroites -- (Science@NASA) Scientists have discovered sugars in a meteorite, adding to the list of complex organic molecules that have been found inside space rocks.

Was Johnny Appleseed a Comet? -- (Science@NASA) A new experiment suggests that comet impacts could have sowed the seeds of life on Earth billions of years ago.

The Moon itself is one big Earth rock: Big Bang, New Moon (SWRI); Making the Moon (NAI); The Moon's Geological History (Windows to the Universe)

Microfossils and chemical fossils: Fossils' fuel (Nature); Fossil Record of the Bacteria (UC Berkeley); Questioning the evidence for Earth's oldest fossils (University of Oxford)

Original link for this page: http://science.nasa.gov/headlines/y2002/18oct_earthrocks.htm