IU Relief
Skip Navigation
Indiana University Bloomington
News and Results
Indiana University Debate

IU Intra-IU Debate TournamentIU podium 2


RESOLVED: Indiana University students should be vegan.

Results Intra-IU Fall 2014:

Click here for more pictures

Final Round 3-2 Decision: Nate Meyers/Neil Brady (Affirmative) win over Jasmine Williams/Clarinda Guevara. IU Team MB are the "top debaters" on campus. IU WG were awarded a close second having proven their strength in advocacy skills.


In the final debate round, Nate and Neil argued for a moral obligation for students to become vegan. Their arguments included well documented claims of environmental concerns related to animals byproducts and meat production in the US as well as arguments about global hunger and the caloric efficiency of vegan food.

Jasmine and Clarinda introduced compelling arguments in how there are healthy and environmentally sound ways to be non-Vegan. Their major "offensive" argument dealt with problems of transition and the implications morality frameworks could have on cultures that are closely tied to meat consumption.

Top Speakers

Judges for each debate ranked the speakers in the debate round from 20-30 speaker points. The top speakers were awarded with IU winter swag (scarves)!

Total Speaks Name Speaker Ranks
88 Nate Meyers Top Speaker
87 Kegan Ferguson 2nd Speaker
85 Neil Brady 3rd Speaker
85 Sabrina Gowda 4th Speaker
84 Jasmine Williams 5th Speaker
83 Marc Pagano
83 Clarinda Guevara
80 Alex Markovits
80 Parantap Mahadevia
79 Lauren Mintzer
79 Mark Werner
78 Keren Landy
75 Sydney Tabb
75 Marina Katz
74 Danielle Posner
36 Addie Wagner
34.5 Taylor Pearson

Tournament Tabulation Information:

POINTS ROUND 1 W = 1 ROUND 2 W = 1 ROUND 3 W = 1 Total Wins Total Speaks
IU PW Addie Wagner 24 0 12   0   0 36 IU PW
  Taylor Pearson 23 0 11.5   0     34.5  
IU FT Sydney Tabb 25 1 26 1 24   2 75 IU FG
  Kegan Ferguson 29   29   29     87  
IU KP Danielle Posner 23   26   25   0 74 IU KP
  Marina Katz 24   27   24     75  
IU LM Keren Landy 25 1 28   25   1 78 IU LM
  Alex Markovits 26   27   27     80  
IU MP Marc Pagano 28   27   28 1 1 83 IU MP
  Lauren Mintzer 27   26   26     79  
IU BM Nate Meyers 30 1 28 1 30 1 3 88 IU BM
  Neil Brady 29   27   29     85  
IU GM Parantap Mahadevia 26 1 26   28 1 2 80 IU GM
  Sabrina Gowda 29   29   27     85  
IU ZW Yi Zhou 24   29 1 28 1 2 81 IU ZW
  Mark Werner 25   28   26     79  
IU GW Jasmine Williams 27 1 29 1 28   2 84 IU GW
  Clarinda Guevara 26   30   27     83  


YOU! Yes, YOU can debate the ethical, social, political, cultural and environmental costs & benefits of consuming animal products!!! vegan pyramid

The Indiana University Debate Team cordially invites all interested Indiana University undergraduate students to participate in the third annual Intra-IU Debate Tournament. This year we are partnering with the College of Arts and Sciences Themester on "Eat, Drink, Think." Students who participate will be eligible to win Indiana University gear purchased from the IU bookstore, bragging rights, and DINNER on us!

Do I Need Prior Experience?

NO! Whether you competed in forensics in high school or you have never watched a debate, this competition is a great place for you to improve on as well as show off your analytical argumentation and public speaking skills. The tournament is a perfect opportunity for you to engage in a fun debate environment with a small amount of time commitment.  The Indiana University Debate Team will provide research, teaching sessions, and talking points for all teams to use as well as instructions on how to compete successfully at the tournament. All we need to complete the picture is YOU!

food pyramidWhat is the Cost?

The cost to competitors is FREE. The tournament is an IU Debate service for undergraduate students on campus. The College of Arts and Sciences, The School of Public and Environmental Affairs, and the Office of Vice Provost of Undergraduate Affairs have provided support and funding for this important event in recognition that debate is a platform with widespread educational benefits. We will provide the space, food/drink, judging and awards at no cost to you.

The winning team, runner-up, and top speaking competitors will receive prizes purchased from the IU Memorial Union Gift Store. 



Registration! Registration!! Registration!!! Registration!!!!

To register, fill out this google form (LINK). If you have a partner, please make sure that they register as well. We would highly suggest that partners attend work sessions together. If you do not have a partner, we will assign one to you as soon as one becomes available. Typically half of the partnerships in this tournament are individuals who signed up who are then combined. It's a great way to meet a new friend!

If you have questions, please send an email to IUDebateTournament@gmail.com, subject-line should include "Intra-IU" in it.

The Deadling for Registration is Friday October 31st.

The Resolution

Resolved: Indiana University students should be vegan.

Why choose veganism as the debate topic? Good question. Given the percentage of people in the United States who eat meat as well as the smaller percentage of those who are vegetarian, we believe that "veganism" as an advocacy is the most significant change to status quo food consumption. Students who attend the Intra-IU debate tournament will need to be able to defend veganism as well as have a strategy against veganism. You will debate "both sides" of the resolution. This means you will need to understandthe ethical, environmental, economic, and health related landscapes that surround the meat and animal product industries. Furthermore, if you are opposed to defending meat eating but believe that veganism is too restrictive, the resolution allows negatives to argue for vegetarian diets, or other permutations of diets that contain meat or animal byproduct.

Most importantly--regardless of your personal politics and eating habits, participating students will have to experience the thoughts and arguments of someone they may not agree with.




The IU Debate team has put together resarch in the areas of environment, health, and ethics for this topic. The evidence is in a dropbox account folder. This evidence should be viewed as a primer for the main arguments that will likely be made by students arguing over a topic dealing with veganism. Students are not limited to this evidence and they are encouraged to do more research to defend what they believe is the "best" perspective/argument on the topic.

Click Link for The Shared Evidence Set (Final version will be posted Oct 15th)

Round Format

1st Affirmative Constructive Speech     5 Minutes
Cross examination                                        1 ½ Minutes
1st Negative                                       5 Minutes
Cross examination                                        1 ½ Minutes
2nd Affirmative Constructive                5 Minutes
Cross Examination                                        1 ½ Minutes
2nd Negative Constructive                   5 Minutes
Cross Examination                                        1 ½ Minutes
Final Negative Rebuttal                        3 Minutes
Final Affirmative Rebuttal                     5 Minutes

Prep time: 3 Minutes
Round Debate Time:
35 Minutes + Decision = 45 Minutes

Tournament Schedule

November 5th, Wednesday Location Ballantine 244

5:45 PM: Welcome, Registration and Dinner
6:30 PM Round 1
7:30 PM Round 2
8:30 PM Round 3
9:45 PM Finals and Awards

What to do from now to the tournament

  1. Register via the google form link above.
  2. You should plan to attend one or more of the practice sessions so you are confident and comfortable with the material and format.
  3. Scan the debate team provided research material, use it to create core speeches against likely opponent arguments. Do more research if you wish to expand the arguments out even further. Our material is a primer, not the "end" of the discussion!



Indiana University

Brian DeLong SPEA #323 1315 E. Tenth Street Bloomington, IN 47405-1701
Phone: (812) 856-7585

Last updated: 06 November 2014
Comments: brdelong@indiana.edu