L517: Advanced Study of the Teaching of Secondary School Reading

RESEARCH PAPER

COURSE LINKS

Home Page

Syllabus

Calendar

Assignments

Oncourse

 

INDEX OF PAGE CONTENTS

 

bullet

Assignment Requirements

bullet

Grading Rubric

Assignment Requirements

You will be required to submit a proposal for this project following these guidelines. Your proposal should be submitted on or before its due date (see the L517 calendar) and should be approved by your instructor before you proceed with your research. Submitting a late proposal will result in a 1/2 letter grade deduction from your final paper grade. Failing to submit a proposal will result in a full letter grade deduction from your final paper grade.

For this assignment you will review the professional literature on a topic that is of particular interest to you, and that is related to literacy and teaching or learning at the secondary school level. The audience for your paper is other pre-service and in-service teachers who want to learn more about the topic, as well as how to make positive changes in their classrooms that are related to the topic. (Your paper can be written for all content area pre-/in-service secondary school teachers, or it can be written for pre-/-in-service secondary school teachers of a specific content area.)  Your paper should include the following information, according to the professional literature that you reviewed:

bullet Background information about the topic. Here you will describe the topic and define any terms that might be misinterpreted or confusing to your audience. Present the issues related to the topic, and if appropriate, the history of the topic.  Also, if according to the professional literature there are conflicting viewpoints about the topic, present those here. Your paper should present a balanced picture of the topic. (Keep in mind that this is not an opinion paper. Your opinion about the topic or issues related to the topic  should not be introduced in the paper. This should simply be a review of the professional literature.)
bullet Concrete, instructional practices or strategies related to the topic. After introducing the topic to your audience in the first part of your paper, the second part of your paper should include practical classroom strategies that teachers/students can use that are directly related to your topic. Include ideas from published sources that content-area teachers  can easily incorporate into their classrooms. These ideas should come from published sources. 

Roughly half to two-thirds of your paper should be devoted to a discussion of the topic, and the other one-third to one-half should be devoted to providing teachers with suggestions for concrete practices and strategies related to the topic.

Following are specific requirements for this research paper. 

Content

Your paper should:

 
bullet

Include an introduction that makes the focus and intent of the paper clear, and that provide an overview of what the reader can expect to learn about in the rest of the paper.

bullet

Have a main focus that is apparent throughout the paper.

bullet Be clearly related to a secondary school literacy issue.
bullet Include factually correct information.
bullet Be based on information that comes from a variety of sources (at least 8 different sources).
bullet Be grounded in published literature.
bullet Clearly explain the topic.
bullet Include concrete instructional practices or strategies related to the issue that teachers could easily incorporate into their classrooms.
bullet Be written for other secondary school teachers.

Format and Style

Your paper should:

bullet Be approximately 8 to 10 double-spaced pages in length, not including your  bibliography.
bullet Include a bibliography of references following a well-accepted bibliographic style. Examples include MLA or APA style.
bullet Site sources within the text following a well-accepted citation style. Examples include MLA or APA style.
bullet Have a clear organization.
bullet Have smooth transitions.
bullet Be written using correct grammar.
bullet Include no spelling errors.

Grading Rubric

 

Each of the following areas will be graded on a 4-point scale (3=excellent; 2=good; 1=fair; 0=poor). Your final score will be out of 21 points.

 

bullet

Introduction: Writing
bullet

Includes a logical and clear organization of ideas from beginning to end.

bullet

Includes appropriate transitions from one idea to the next.

bullet

If the introduction includes more than one paragraph, there are appropriate transitions from one paragraph to the next.

bullet

Each paragraph focuses on one subject.

bullet

Grammar, punctuation, and spelling are correct.

bullet

Introduction: Content
bullet

The focus/intent of the paper is clearly expressed.

bullet

The focus/intent is logical and appropriate for the audience.

bullet

The focus/intent is clearly related to secondary school literacy.

bullet

An overview of what the reader can expect to learn about in the rest of the paper is provided.

bullet

No personal opinions of the author are expressed.

bullet

Background information: Writing
bullet

Includes a logical and clear organization of ideas from beginning to end.

bullet

Includes appropriate transitions from one idea to the next, and from one paragraph to the next.

bullet

Each paragraph focuses on one subject.

bullet

Grammar, punctuation, and spelling are correct.

bullet

Background information: Content
bullet

Ideas are clearly developed.

bullet

Any unclear or ambiguous terms are defined.

bullet

It is clear what all information has to do with the overarching topic, and the inclusions of all information seems logical given the audience and intent of your paper.

bullet

All major issues/well-known viewpoints are presented.

bullet

No personal opinions of the author are expressed.

bullet

Instructional practices/strategies: Writing
bullet

Includes a logical and clear organization of ideas from beginning to end.

bullet

Includes appropriate transitions from one idea to the next, and from one paragraph to the next.

bullet

Each paragraph focuses on one subject.

bullet

Grammar, punctuation, and spelling are correct.

bullet

Instructional practices/strategies: Content
bullet

All practices/strategies are explained with enough detail that a teacher could incorporate them into his/her classroom without needing to do more research of his/her own.

bullet

It is clear how all strategies/practices are related to the overarching topic, and the inclusions of all strategies/practices seems logical given the audience and intent of your paper.

bullet

Parenthetical notations/Bibliography
bullet

It is clear from the parenthetical notations to whom all ideas expressed in the are attributed.

bullet

Parenthetical notations and bibliography follow a well-accepted style, such as APA or MLA.

bullet

At least 8 professional, published sources are referred to in the paper and appear in the bibliography. (Professional, published sources include published books, doctoral dissertations, and peer-reviewed journal articles. If you are using information from another source as one of the required 8 and you are not certain it is from an acceptable source, please e-mail your instructor.)

Last updated: 06/07/2006, by Jennifer Conner
URL: http://www.indiana.edu/~l517/rp.html
Comments: jmconner@indiana.edu
Copyright 2006, Jennifer Conner