
|
L517: Advanced Study of the Teaching of Secondary School Reading CHOOSING APPROPRIATE TEXTS |

|
COURSE LINKS |
INDEX OF PAGE CONTENTS
Reading Assignment
LectureWhile we may not be fortunate enough to have a say in what textbooks we will use in our classrooms, we will certainly be able to choose the texts that supplement our lessons. These might be trade books (books that were written to be sold to the public at bookstores), magazine articles, newspaper articles, portions of other textbooks, web sites etc. When we choose texts for our students we have to think about issues like the following:
Questions one through four above are examples of questions that we ask to determine whether a text is "reader friendly" or "considerate." This is often determined by using a checklist such as this one: General Readability Checklist. (Here is a Readability Checklist for Informational Web Pages.) The last question above (question five) has to do with a text's "readability." (Readability is simply defined as the relationship between the reading level of a student and the difficulty of the text.) This is often determined using a formula such as the Fry Readability Formula. Readability formulas yield estimates of textbook difficulty. They usually involve taking a measure of sentence length and word difficulty do determine a grade-level score for texts. It is important to keep in mind that just because a formula indicates that a text is written at the 8th grade level, that does not mean that it is ideal for 8th graders. (It might be. But it might not be.) Readability formulas provide you with one piece of evidence that must be used in conjunction with other evidence (e.g., the extent to which the text is reader friendly) to determine its appropriateness for your students. While we make a point of choosing texts that include features that support our students' efforts to read and comprehend, we have to remember that our students may not always know how to make the best use of all of those features. Research suggests that many students do not use the table of contents or index to help them find information (Dreher, 1992). Furthermore some students are not aware of the organization of their textbook, even after they have been reading information from it for some time. For many students the problem is that they simply do not take the time to make themselves aware of the features and organization of their textbook. They never familiarize themselves with the overall content and layout of their book. They merely read the pages they're assigned and ignore the rest. One way to encourage your students to become familiar with the various features of your textbook as well as to get a feel for the overall layout and organization of it is to create a textbook scavenger hunt. Decide what features of your textbook you want your students to be particularly aware of. Then write questions designed to encourage your students to review those features. The scavenger hunt can be completed by students independently or in small groups. Be sure to review the answers with your students when they are done, and be sure to ask them what steps they took to find the answers to your questions. This will let you know how effectively they've used the different features of their textbook. You might even ask them to write down how they found the answers as part of answering each question. (Here is an example of a textbook scavenger hunt-- Textbook Scavenger Hunt: The Americas.) Dreher, M. J. (1992). Searching for information in textbooks. Journal of Reading, 35(5), pp. 364-371.
Oncourse ActivityIf you have any questions about how to post to Oncourse or what your responsibilities are for posting to Oncourse, please visit the L517 Posting to Oncourse web page.
ORIGINAL POSTING--By the end of the day on
Wednesday of this week post your response to the
following topic on Oncourse.
Task 1: Using the Fry Readability Formula, determine the readability of our L517 textbook. Focus just on chapter 1 of our text. Then, using the General Readability Checklist, indicate whether you think chapter 1 of our textbook rates the highest in understandability, usability, or interest. Explain why. Likewise, indicate for which of these categories you think our textbook rates the lowest. Explain why. Task 2: Pretend like your L517 textbook is really a secondary school textbook and your partner is really a secondary school student. Over the years that you've been teaching at the secondary school level it has become clear to you that most secondary school students don't know how to use their textbooks. They are not familiar with the different sections of their textbook that are meant to support their own learning, and when they do stumble on the table of contents or glossary, they don't always seem to know what to do with it. Create a textbook scavenger hunt for your partner, using your L517 textbook. Include about 5 items. (That's obviously a bit short if you were creating a scavenger hunt for a real class of students. But for the purposes of simply getting some experience thinking about and writing a scavenger hunt, 5 items will work fine.) Try to write scavenger hunt items that will help your students (your partner) become familiar with and use the different parts of the textbook.
RESPONSE TO PARTNER'S POSTING--By the end of the day on
Friday
of this week respond to your partner's posting.
Task 1: Read your partner's posting to see to what extent your partner's responses agree with your own. Did your Fry Readability results come out the same? Did you rate chapter 1 of your textbook the same using the Readability Checklist? If there are differences, comment on those differences. What do you think accounts for the differences? If there are no differences, you might post something like, "Looks like we agreed on everything," and leave it at that. Task 2: Complete your partner's scavenger hunt and post your answers. Also, from an educator's perspective, comment on the scavenger hunt itself. Would it be a good start in getting students to become more familiar with their texts? Why or why not?
CLOSING WORDS
--By the end of of the day
on Sunday, read your
group's and one other group's postings for this topic and then reflect on both.
|

Last updated:
06/30/2006, by Jennifer Conner
URL: http://www.indiana.edu/~l517/textbooks.htm
Comments: jmconner@indiana.edu
Copyright 2006, Jennifer Conner